By now I had some time to think about what I am trying to achieve and why:
- I want a game that appeals to those of my players who like Fate.
- I want to have a replacement for the current rules set of Vampire: The Masquerade and Vampire: The Requiem available because I find VtM deeply flawed system- and setting-wise, and I don't really like the changes to VtR 2.0. On top of that I find both systems cumbersome.
- I want a game about vampires, because they continue to fascinate me, and they are the Urban Fantasy I am most comfortable with.
- I want to use Fate because it is an OGL/Create Commons licensed game engine that easier to hack compared to PtbA. Also Fate is enjoying quite the popularity.
After defining what I want and why, let's take a look at the Vampire games (Masquerade and Requiem) and see what I think their strengths are:
- A rich and deep mythology, especially VtM shines with its Caine myth.
- Turning vampirism in a struggle vs. self through mechanics (namely humanity and frenzy).
- Emphasizing the dependency of a vampire on blood; portraying the vampire as an addict.
- Faction wars (or rather intrigues) that put the actions of a single character into a greater context.
But I still wanted my game to be different. Therefore I introduced things like mythology and city creation, etc. That was an attempt to differentiate Fate, Blood & Sevens Sins as a toolbox for building your own unique vampire game (kind of like Vampire City). But I realize now that I already have a strong vision of things I want in a vampire game and things I don't want to be there. So, instead of a toolbox the next time around it will be mythology of my own devising. Probably there'll be parallels to existing mythology, but mostly it's planned as a grounding for the game to give it a stronger hook.
What also needs to be differentiated is the genre of the game. VtM and VtR both lean heavily in the direction of horror and intrigue. I know that both games often hit the table as "superheroes with fangs" or an intrigue-load that turns people off. Also, Gothic music still shows its influences heavily in the games. So I am not sure yet, if Fate, Blood & Seven Sins should do things differently. Personally, I like the slick and stylish aesthetics of movies like Blade, Underworld and We are the Night, or the creepy horror of Byzantium and Let the Right One In, or the languid atmosphere of Only Lovers Left Alive.
At the moment, the only thing I have nailed down firmly in my opinion are the Seven Sins. They replace the FAE approaches for doing things. Their definition seems to be valid, in so far that they all do very specific things. Expect to see them here soonish.
That's it. This where I stand, and where my ideas are taking me.